Home > Forums > General Discussions > Tha Yard > Archives > Tha Graveyard(2004)
Edit Settings  |  Search Forums
Brotherhood or Brotha-hood Posted on 06-16-2004
REALity

I wanna get some opinions on this. I know there is somewhat of a sense of brotherhood/sisterhood in the black community. My question is, is a white man/woman any less my brother or sister than a black man? If so, why?
  [Reply]
Page 2 of 3 First  < 123  >  Last
HU_Intellect replied on 06-16-2004 03:55PM [Reply]
I think being black automatically gives you at least somewhat of a connection because you are part of the black community and share many of the same hardships and tribulations. Just because we may have a white friend that we have grown up with who acts "black" (what is acting black?), when we get in the real world we are still going to be prejudged and stereotyped as black people. However, that being sad not all black people share the same bond by any means. We are all different and many share different experiences and views on life. So I have to say this one isn't as clear as "Black and White", but we all SHOULD share a brotherhood at least theoretically.
  [Report Abuse] [Quote]
hot_coco from Queens, NY replied on 06-16-2004 04:37PM [Reply]

Even though we as Black people share common goals and stuggles, we are a very diverse people (like any other race). We come from different social and economic backrounds. We have different cultures and ways of speaking. We also have different experiences throughout our lives. But, instead of letting these differences divide us (especially since we have so many other people trying to divide us already), we should bring our differences together and form that brotherhood and sisterhood among each other. If everyone in the community showed that brotherly love towards each other, we could help each other alleviate many our own problems.
  [Report Abuse] [Quote]
G.O.M.A.B. replied on 06-16-2004 04:40PM [Reply]
hot_coco wrote:
Even though we as Black people share common goals and stuggles, we are a very diverse people (like any other race). We come from different social and economic backrounds. We have different cultures and ways of speaking. We also have different experiences throughout our lives. But, instead of letting these differences divide us (especially since we have so many other people trying to divide us already), we should bring our differences together and form that brotherhood and sisterhood among each other. If everyone in the community showed that brotherly love towards each other, we could help each otherher alleviate many our own problems.
er..uh...Was this supposed to be a public service announcement?
  [Report Abuse] [Quote]
hot_coco from Queens, NY replied on 06-16-2004 05:47PM [Reply]

^^^it's really just my opinion....but take how you will, i guess
  [Report Abuse] [Quote]
NASDAQ_J replied on 06-16-2004 10:52PM [Reply]
8)
  [Report Abuse] [Quote]
replied on 06-17-2004 03:21AM [Reply]
NeoSoulBrotha wrote:
I think it has more to do with life experience than just color of skin. There are Blacks that I would feel little or no connection towards, based upon their patterns of behavior and position in life. On ther other hand, there are White people who grew up in similar circumstances to mine, share the same attitudes and experiences, and have similar goals and asipirations. So I'd have to say no. Just because two Black people are standing next to each other doesn't mean that they are automatically going to be instant buddies, as if their Blackness just radiates around them like Kryptonite. However, they are more likely to, because we've been brought up in an environment where Blacks generally have more of an open mind towards other Blacks as opposed to those of other ethnic backgrounds. But I think it is the result of cultural bias, not lack of intellectual or spiritual bonds. Holla!
this man is on point
  [Edit] [Delete] [Report Abuse] [Quote]
replied on 06-17-2004 09:39AM [Reply]
Yes, what NeoSoulBrotha said was profound and shows that he does think outside the box. However, are we talking about actual brotherhood or just making friendships? I think that brotherhood goes beyond connecting with like minded individuals. This is creating a personal bond with somebody which is a little different. Does brotherhood limit itself to people who have gone through similar experiences? Maybe, the brotherhood that King was reaching for was the feeling of unconditional love for someone just because they exist, regardless of race, background, or beliefs. For example, if our minds are in this state of brotherhood at all times, no matter where we are we would feel at home. How many of us feel less comfortable if we're the minority in a large room or at an event? It's because the sense of brotherhood is absent. So if we can (which we can) substitute our current idea of brotherhood, with one that encompasses all in the exchange of LOVE with no bars, and actually apply it to our lives, we have a foundation for improving life on this planet.
  [Edit] [Delete] [Report Abuse] [Quote]
Slim GoodyN757 replied on 06-17-2004 01:18PM [Reply]
REALity wrote:
Yes, what NeoSoulBrotha said was profound and shows that he does think outside the box. However, are we talking about actual brotherhood or just making friendships? I think that brotherhood goes beyond connecting with like minded individuals. This is creating a personal bond with somebody which is a little different. Does brotherhood limit itself to people who have gone through similar experiences? Maybe, the brotherhood that King was reaching for was the feeling of unconditional love for someone just because they exist, regardless of race, background, or beliefs. For example, if our minds are in this state of brotherhood at all times, no matter where we are we would feel at home. How many of us feel less comfortable if we're the minority in a large room or at an event? It's because the sense of brotherhood is absent. So if we can (which we can) substitute our current idea of brotherhood, with one that encompasses all in the exchange of LOVE with no bars, and actually apply it to our lives, we have a foundation for improving life on this planet.
Bravo!! bravo!!! Well said
  [Report Abuse] [Quote]
PrinceMannyX from columbus, OH replied on 06-18-2004 01:07PM [Reply]

NeoSoulBrotha wrote:
I think it has more to do with life experience than just color of skin. There are Blacks that I would feel little or no connection towards, based upon their patterns of behavior and position in life. On ther other hand, there are White people who grew up in similar circumstances to mine, share the same attitudes and experiences, and have similar goals and asipirations. So I'd have to say no. Just because two Black people are standing next to each other doesn't mean that they are automatically going to be instant buddies, as if their Blackness just radiates around them like Kryptonite. However, they are more likely to, because we've been brought up in an environment where Blacks generally have more of an open mind towards other Blacks as opposed to those of other ethnic backgrounds. But I think it is the result of cultural bias, not lack of intellectual or spiritual bonds. Holla!
Al-hamdulillah
  [Report Abuse] [Quote]
Slim GoodyN757 replied on 06-18-2004 01:15PM [Reply]
^^^He's backkkkkkkkkkk
  [Report Abuse] [Quote]
Reply To Topic
In order to post a response to this topic, please login below or click here to signup.
Email Address:
Password:
Page 2 of 3 First  < 123  >  Last
Home > Forums > General Discussions > Tha Yard > Archives > Tha Graveyard(2004)
Sponsored Content Create an Ad
Follow Us!
Link To Us!
Do you have a website? Link to HBCU Connect!