If you going to say overall, it going to be Em. This debate isn'r really fair for Paul tho. They're different types of rappers entertaining different types of people. Eminem has also had a longer career and much better support production wise. DJ Michael Watts and Mike Jones dont have anything on Dr. Dre and 50. If your the type of person who favors quality lyrics over party anthems than you going for Em. If party anthems are your thing then you probably gon like Paul. I like both genres and artists for what they are. Just keep an open mind. You never know what you might be noddin' your head to.