"For Many Poor Black Girls, Teen Pregnancy Is A Rational Choice"
|
Posted By: WILLIAM W. HEMMANS III on August 14, 2008 *I came across this article, what are your thoughts if any? I have my view points..." For Many Poor Black Girls, Teen Pregnancy Is A Rational Choice Posted by Ampersand | September 22nd, 2005 There’s a lot of talk about ending teen pregnancy (although by “teen pregnancy” most people really mean unwed teen pregnancy). Many people worry about unwed teen pregnancy as the cause of poverty, especially of Black poverty (something like 70% of current births among African-Americans are to single mothers). And they talk about teen pregnancy as if it were a pathology. I think the pathology model is mistaken. Poverty is a cause of high teen pregnancy rates, rather than vice-versa. And poor black teens aren’t pathological; they’re rational actors, who make the best choice they can given the opportunities they have. When high rates of some population - in this case, poor girls and especially poor Blacks - get pregnant, then chances are getting pregnant is a good choice for their circumstances. If we want less pregnancy among poor black teens, then we need to reorder society so that poor black teens face a better set of circumstances. There’s an argument that, for many poor teens, unwed teen pregnancy is a rational choice given their circumstances. If we want to change the choices they make, we have to change their circumstances until it is no longer a rational choice for them to get pregnant as a teenager. Why is unwed teen pregnancy a rational choice? 1) For teens raised in poor (and statistically more likely to be polluted) areas, with lousy food and lousy medical care, their health will probably peak at around ages 17-19. That makes the teenage years a much better time to give birth than later years. Among poor black girls and women, the infant mortality rate is twice as high among those who wait until their 20s to give birth as it is for those who give birth in their teens. 2) For those who will be relying on an extended family of older female relatives to help with childcare and support, it makes sense to give birth when mothers, aunts and older cousins are younger and more able to offer assistance. Furthermore, grandmothers may feel more obligated to offer extensive aid to their 16-year-old pregnant daughter than to their 26-year-old pregnant daughter. 3) For middle-class whites, the opportunity costs (aka “what you give up”ť) of early childbirth are enormous; college and early career-building are made much harder by a baby or two in tow. Furthermore, the odds of eventually getting married and having a healthy child in wedlock are very good for middle-class teens who wait until they’re women to marry and have children. For poor teens of color, in contrast, the opportunity costs of early childbirth are much lower. Poor teens can see that their odds of affording a good college followed by a high-paying, high-status career are low. And for poor black girls, the odds of finding someone suitable to marry during peak childbearing years - or even during their 20s - are much lower. So overall, poor girls of color have much less reason to delay childbearing. Studies have shown that, for poor women of color, economic outcomes aren’t much different for girls who wait to become mothers in their 20s than they are for girls who become mothers in their teens. One study I read (which I’ve seen referred to by Arline Geronimus, but not by others) compared sisters who became mothers at different times in their lives, for example, and found that the future income was about the same regardless of the time of first birth. At this point, therefore, it’s no wonder that so many poor teens see no reason to put off motherhood. Rationally, they’re as well off - or better off - becoming a mother in their teens. If we want to change teen pregnancy, we need to change the circumstances of poor girls’ lives - and especially the lives of poor black girls - until their most rational choice is to put motherhood off until they’re in their mid-twenties and married. Circumstances that need changing include, but aren’t limited to: 1) The provision of easy-access, super-cheap universal health care. The model should be France’s, where anyone can walk into any general practitioner’s office and make an appointment without having to navigate any bureaucracies or pay out of pocket. 2) Middle-class, attractive jobs need to become widely available for poor folks. 3) There need to be far, far fewer black men of marriageable age in jail and prison. 4) Detriments to health that are especially common in areas where poor folks live - things like lead paint, poor quality food, pollution, etc - need to be effectively mitigated or eliminated. 5) College education and attractive career paths after college need to become likely possibilities for poor girls - even for those who are mediocre scholars. Just as such paths are now available for middle-class and wealthy boys even if they’re mediocre scholars. 6) Much, much more serious work fighting the racism and sexism that (among many other causes) holds back women of color. Affirmative action programs should be returned to their strong forms, which haven’t existed since before the Reagan administration. I used to wonder if I was the only liberal who thought this way. Then, a few days ago, I came across a reference to Arline Geronimus on a feminist econ list I read. She’s done a lot of research on rational choice and teen pregnancy; much of this post is drawn from her work. If you enjoyed this article, Join HBCU CONNECT today for similar content and opportunities via email! |
 |
WILLIAM W. HEMMANS III
CRT 1st Response Case Manager, Mental Health Care,, Florida A&M University class of 1995 Member Since February 2004 |
Comments
More From This Author
Latest Blogs
 |
The New 2026 Subaru Forester Wilderness is an AdventureAfter a week of test-driving the new 2026 Subaru Forester Wilderness through the beltways and backroads of the D.C., Maryland, and Virginia (DMV) area, in both dry and wet weather, I can share how thi ...more
Randi Payton • 49 Views • March 15th, 2026 |
 |
College Road Trip 101: The Most Powerful Series Production Minivan Ever MadePerformance is a relative thing. For example, if you have a modern, high-tech supercar that looks sensational, but only makes 250 horsepower, that would be a huge letdown. However, should a company ma ...more
How May I Help You NC • 96 Views • March 12th, 2026 |
 |
“Looking for her Matt” 🐼 Mattel has a few gifts to add to an “Action-Packed Easter Baskets” Big Brother says his kids love flipping through his car magazines asking to test drive the latest Mustang or the sleekest Porsche 💨
Dads grab your wife and head to the nearest retail shop to ...more
How May I Help You NC • 105 Views • March 12th, 2026 |
 |
Join us for a day of golf, networking and purpose. FORE the Children Golf Tournament
FORE the Children Golf Tournament
April 24, 2026 | 7:30 am - 3:00 pm
Hawks Landing Golf Course
BUY FOURSOMES
DONATE
VIEW SPONSORSHIP OPPORTUNITIES
https://chsfl.org/events/fore-the-childre ...more
How May I Help You NC • 94 Views • March 12th, 2026 |
 |
WHAT PRODUCT WILL GET THEE SPRING CLEANING KNOCKED OUTSo there’s a stain in the carpet and we gotta act fast before it sets in🧃
•I say OXYDOL is first choice
There is a lot of graffiti on thee neighborhood fixtures 📛🦡
• ...more
How May I Help You NC • 117 Views • March 11th, 2026 |
Popular Blogs
 |
Divorce in America in 2009 – What’s love got to do, got to do with it?
Join Brother Marcus and the cast and the crew of the Brother Marcus Show live this Sunday evening on February 1, 2009 @ 8:00 p.m. for another hot topic in our community! “Divorce in America in 2009 ...more
Brother Marcus! • 70,904,538 Views • January 27th, 2009 |
 |
VISINE ALERT!!!Seemingly innocent medication such as Visine eyedrops are used by people to concoct a mixture with similar effects as a date-rape drug.
When mixed with alcohol and taken orally, the eyedrops can l ...more
Siebra Muhammad • 118,603 Views • May 23rd, 2009 |
 |
"Chain Hang Low" check out the real meaning of the Lyrics!Recently there is a new artist out of Saint Louis that goes by the name JIBBS. Jibbs debut single "Chain hang low" has a history that most people are not aware of. The particular nursery rhyme that th ...more
Tyhesha Judge-Fogle • 76,127 Views • November 9th, 2006 |
 |
HBCU Marketplace Gifts: Divine 9 Premium Fraternity / Sorority Playing CardsVendor: Charles Jones
Item Price: $20.00
Price Includes Shipping: Yes - Shipping Included
Item Description:
Pantheon Series - Divine 9 - Premium Playing Cards (choose Gold Series or Silve ...more
How May I Help You NC • 61,859 Views • December 2nd, 2018 |
